My son saw a photo of the Rope ‘N Ride Ranch and immediately said, “where’s the smokestack?”
Quick to be helpful, I answered, “It’s right over h… uh… where’s the smokestack?”
That’s right. Geotrax, well known for their great detail (check out the horseshoe prints on the hill), forgot to put a smokestack on this steamer.
This is an engine reminiscent of the classic 4–4-0 American. But it doesn’t have a tender, either; that only leaves three options.
- Maybe it’s a saddle tanker (just being obvious here, since it has saddle tanks on the sides). But a saddle tanker needs a smokestack, so this really isn’t an option after all.
- Maybe it’s a “fireless.” That’s the only kind of steam engine without a smokestack; it’s just a big tank that would be charged with steam. But then it doesn’t need the saddle tanks, so what’s up?
- Maybe it’s a fake — a gas or diesel or electric engine that just has a steam-like facade built around it. We frequently take rides on a similar “steam engine” locally. Unlikely, though, since they are placing this in the era of the Old West. The great irony of this possibility, of course, is that it really is an electric engine made to look like a steam engine.
While I’m whining about picky little things, I might as well give you one more: the Amazon page linked above lists the engine’s name as “Rusty the Steam Engine.” Not quite right: Fisher-Price named it “Old Rust” and even trademarked the name.
2 responses so far ↓
1 Curtis // Oct 29, 2007 at 7:41 pm
I *thought* that engine looked funny, but I never realized it had no smokestack!
How to add one? An appropritely sized dowel, perhaps?
2 Miles // Oct 20, 2008 at 8:05 pm
Use your rudimentary modeling skills to make it look more realistic. The Dowel is a nice idea. If you’re serious about improving the appearance of this little diappointment, I would also fix the valve gear (the rods that transfer motion from the cylinders on the side to the driving wheels)
Use this for a good reference for a side tank 0–4-0 http://gold.mylargescale.com/Scottychaos/G-Roustabout.gif
Leave a Comment