TrainDad

My son loves trains, so I'm along for the ride.

TrainDad random header image

Geotrax, you’re insulting my 3-year-old’s intelligence!

October 1st, 2007 · 2 Comments

My son saw a photo of the Rope ‘N Ride Ranch and imme­di­ately said, “where’s the smokestack?”

Quick to be help­ful, I answered, “It’s right over h… uh… where’s the smokestack?”

That’s right. Geo­t­rax, well known for their great detail (check out the horse­shoe prints on the hill), for­got to put a smoke­stack on this steamer.

This is an engine rem­i­nis­cent of the clas­sic 4–4-0 Amer­i­can. But it doesn’t have a ten­der, either; that only leaves three options.

  1. Maybe it’s a sad­dle tanker (just being obvi­ous here, since it has sad­dle tanks on the sides). But a sad­dle tanker needs a smoke­stack, so this really isn’t an option after all.
  2. Maybe it’s a “fire­less.” That’s the only kind of steam engine with­out a smoke­stack; it’s just a big tank that would be charged with steam. But then it doesn’t need the sad­dle tanks, so what’s up?
  3. Maybe it’s a fake — a gas or diesel or elec­tric engine that just has a steam-like facade built around it. We fre­quently take rides on a sim­i­lar “steam engine” locally. Unlikely, though, since they are plac­ing this in the era of the Old West. The great irony of this pos­si­bil­ity, of course, is that it really is an elec­tric engine made to look like a steam engine.

While I’m whin­ing about picky lit­tle things, I might as well give you one more: the Ama­zon page linked above lists the engine’s name as “Rusty the Steam Engine.” Not quite right: Fisher-Price named it “Old Rust” and even trade­marked the name.

Tags: Train Toys

2 responses so far ↓

  • 1 Curtis // Oct 29, 2007 at 7:41 pm

    I *thought* that engine looked funny, but I never real­ized it had no smoke­stack!
    How to add one? An appro­pritely sized dowel, perhaps?

  • 2 Miles // Oct 20, 2008 at 8:05 pm

    Use your rudi­men­tary mod­el­ing skills to make it look more real­is­tic. The Dowel is a nice idea. If you’re seri­ous about improv­ing the appear­ance of this lit­tle diap­point­ment, I would also fix the valve gear (the rods that trans­fer motion from the cylin­ders on the side to the dri­ving wheels)

    Use this for a good ref­er­ence for a side tank 0–4-0 http://gold.mylargescale.com/Scottychaos/G-Roustabout.gif

Leave a Comment